Skip to content

ChatGPT Ads vs. Google Search Ads: What Do the First Numbers Say?

5 min read
ChatGPT Ads против Google Search Ads: что говорят первые цифры? — illustration 1

In the world of digital marketing, where every advertising dollar counts, the emergence of a new player always sparks heated discussions. With the arrival of ChatGPT Ads on the scene, many are wondering: is it time to reconsider established strategies and reallocate budgets from proven channels like Google Search? Initial figures and studies show that the claim of a profitable CPM in ChatGPT Ads remains a myth for now, and the unit economics of the new platform significantly lag behind the search advertising giant.

Comparison of Profitability: ChatGPT Ads Loses to Google Search

OpenAI, which launched its ChatGPT Ads advertising platform in February and reached an annual run rate of $1 billion by August 31, is actively competing for advertising budgets. However, according to a recent study, the profitability per ad visit in ChatGPT Ads is significantly lower than that of Google Search.

  • Revenue per session: $0.89 for ChatGPT Ads vs. $2.45 for Google paid search (US data).
  • Transactions per session: 0.37% for ChatGPT Ads vs. 1.17% for Google Search.

These figures are aggregated over 60 weeks (up to August 22), with up to 28 weeks of US traffic data available for ChatGPT Ads. The study analyzed 102 websites, 20% of which represented services, software, education, and finance sectors.

Cost Per Click and Value for Money

If each session is considered a paid click, the cost vs. result ratio looks like this:

  • Google Search: $3.40 in revenue for every advertising dollar ($2.45 / $0.72).
  • ChatGPT Ads: $0.52 in revenue for every advertising dollar ($0.89 / $1.72).

According to the study authors, an ad visit from ChatGPT brings approximately three times less value at a price 2.4 times higher. The study abstract states that ChatGPT Ads are worth less than one-sixth of the value for money of Google Search. This means that to achieve the same ROI as in Google Search, the price in ChatGPT Ads must be 6.57 times lower.

Methodology Issues and Data from OpenAI

The study is based on data provided by Grips Intelligence, where one of the authors is a scientific advisor. OpenAI, commenting on the study, stated that it “covers an early period of ChatGPT Ads development and extrapolates platform performance based on a small sample.”

“The study covers an early period of ChatGPT Ads development and extrapolates platform performance based on a small sample,” – OpenAI representative.

It is important to note that OpenAI is constantly updating its platform, adding new features such as Target CPA and Target CPC. These innovations were not taken into account in the study, as the data was collected before their implementation.

ChatGPT Ads vs. Google Search Ads: What Do the First Numbers Say? — illustration 2

Agency Cases: Early Stage and High CPCs

Several agencies shared their experience with the new platform:

  • Opascope: spent $60,000 in 15 days, achieved 1.49x ROAS. CPC was $1.72.
  • Workshop Digital: spent $2,319. CPC for ChatGPT Ads was $3.14 (vs. $6.76 for Google Search). CTR ChatGPT Ads – 1.1%, Google – 5.2%.
  • Brafton: spent $1,524.11 on 263 clicks and one lead. Paid Media Director, Zach Shah, noted that ChatGPT Ads “are priced like search, but behave like paid social.”

These cases show that cheap hypothesis testing in ChatGPT Ads is not yet guaranteed, and the cost per click can be high with low conversion.

Important Questions Before Reallocating Budget

Before deciding to reallocate advertising budgets, the following points must be considered:

  1. Comparison of actual expenses and revenues: It is necessary to compare data for the same period with identical attribution settings.
  2. Test sample size: A weak result may be due to a small amount of data, not poor channel performance. A sufficient volume of sessions is needed for accurate evaluation.
  3. Definition of a qualified lead: For lead generation, it is important to define a qualified lead identically across both channels.
  4. Differences between clicks and sessions: Analytics systems may count traffic differently, which affects the final metrics.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is considered a profitable CPM?

A profitable CPM depends on your niche and product margin. In this context, if CPM in ChatGPT Ads leads to significantly lower revenue per session and ROAS, then even a low CPM may not be profitable.

What is cheaper: banner or targeted ads?

This study does not compare banner advertising with targeted advertising. However, by analogy with ChatGPT Ads, targeted advertising, at a higher cost per click, should provide significantly higher conversion and profitability to be profitable.

Is AI advertising worth the money?

Early data shows that AI advertising in ChatGPT Ads does not yet demonstrate sufficient effectiveness compared to Google Search. However, the platform is actively developing, and new features may change the situation. The price per minute of AI video with an avatar or the price of generating 100 AI videos are separate metrics that do not reflect the overall effectiveness of the advertising platform.

Conclusion: Count Cash, Not Hype

Currently, ChatGPT Ads is not a budget alternative to seeding or influencers, and does not demonstrate competitiveness with Google Search in key ROI metrics. The numbers speak for themselves: profitability per dollar invested is significantly lower, and the cost per click is higher. For a mathematical arbitrageur, it is clear: without a radical improvement in unit economics, reallocating budgets to ChatGPT Ads is a significant risk. We continue to monitor the platform’s development, but for now, Google Search remains the king of ROI. Before making a decision, conduct your own testing with adequate data volumes and clear metrics. Learn how to correctly calculate ROI for your campaigns and make informed decisions!


← Back to blog